Why 20% Returns in Syndications Should Make You Pause
For years, one number has dominated conversations around real estate syndications:
20% returns.
It shows up in pitch decks, investor conversations, and expectations. Somewhere along the way, it almost became the benchmark.
But there’s a question we don’t ask often enough:
What does it actually take to generate a 20% return?
Because in most cases, those returns don’t come for free. They come with assumptions. And those assumptions carry risk.
The Reality Check: When the Environment Changes
Over the past few years, we’ve seen a real-world stress test of syndication investing.
Many deals that were put together between 2019 and 2022 were built on a certain set of expectations:
- Low interest rates
- Steady rent growth
- Easy refinancing
Then things changed.
Starting in 2022, the Federal Reserve raised interest rates at one of the fastest paces in recent history. The federal funds rate moved from near zero to over 5% in a relatively short period of time.
That shift had a cascading effect on real estate:
- Borrowing costs increased significantly
- Cash flow projections tightened or broke
- Cap rates expanded, leading to lower property valuations
Deals that looked solid when debt was cheap suddenly faced pressure. Some operators had to inject additional capital to keep properties afloat. Others saw returns fall well below projections. In more severe cases, investors lost part—or all—of their equity.
If you personally know a few people who had this experience, you’re not alone.
Does That Mean Syndication Is a Bad Investment?
Not really.
What it highlights is something more important:
The structure of syndication is not the issue. The way deals are underwritten is.
Just like in stocks, where some companies are stable and others are speculative, syndications also exist across a wide spectrum of risk.
Which brings us to an important idea that doesn’t get enough attention.
Yes, Conservative Syndications Do Exist
They just don’t lead with flashy numbers.
A conservative syndication typically focuses less on maximizing returns and more on protecting capital. That shows up in a few key ways:
- Lower leverage, so the deal isn’t overly dependent on debt
- Fixed-rate financing, reducing exposure to interest rate swings
- Realistic rent growth assumptions instead of aggressive projections
- Strong in-place cash flow rather than relying entirely on future upside
- Sufficient reserves to handle unexpected situations
Because of this, the projected returns are usually more modest.
You’ll often see something in the range of 10% to 15%, instead of 18% to 22%.
At first glance, that may not feel as exciting. But it raises a more meaningful question:
Are you investing to chase the highest possible return, or to build wealth in a way that is sustainable?
Why Investors Choose Syndications in the First Place
To answer that, it helps to step back and look at what syndications actually offer.
1. Diversification Beyond Stocks
A lot of investors today have the majority of their capital tied to equities—through index funds, RSUs, or retirement accounts.
Real estate provides exposure to a completely different asset class, one that has been tested over hundreds of years. More importantly, it behaves differently from stocks because it is tied to physical assets and basic human needs like housing.
Adding syndications to a portfolio can reduce overall concentration risk rather than increase it.
2. Tax Advantages Similar to Direct Ownership
One of the biggest benefits of multifamily syndications is that investors receive the same tax advantages as if they owned the property directly.
This includes:
- Depreciation
- Bonus depreciation (subject to current tax laws)
- The ability to offset passive income
For many investors, these tax benefits meaningfully improve the after-tax outcome of their investment.
3. A Truly Passive Way to Invest in Real Estate
Owning real estate directly can be rewarding, but it also requires time and effort:
- Finding the right deal
- Managing tenants
- Handling maintenance and repairs
- Dealing with vacancies
Syndications allow investors to participate in real estate without taking on these responsibilities. You benefit from professional management and larger, more scalable assets, while remaining passive.
Rethinking How You Evaluate Returns
It’s easy to compare deals based on projected returns alone.
But projections are only as good as the assumptions behind them.
A deal projecting a 20% return often relies on:
- Aggressive rent growth
- Favorable refinancing conditions
- Tight execution timelines
When those assumptions don’t hold, the outcome can look very different from the original projection.
On the other hand, a deal projecting 10% to 15% returns may be built on more conservative assumptions, with a stronger emphasis on downside protection.
Final Thought
There is such a thing as conservative syndication investing.
It may not promise the highest returns, but it aligns better with what many investors are actually trying to achieve:
- Diversification
- Tax efficiency
- Passive income
- Long-term wealth creation
If a syndication delivers moderate returns in the 10% to 15% range while preserving capital and maintaining stability, it is still doing its job.
In many cases, it is doing it better.
Because in the long run, staying invested matters more than chasing the highest projected return.
Leave a Reply